A consumer devoted to Scrub Daddy's social media-famous sponges shared their dismay after discovering the shelf life of their purchases had drastically declined, leading one person to speculate the brand's new partnership may be playing a role and later the brand itself to intervene to report it is dealing with counterfeit products at several popular online retailers.
What's happening?
In the r/CleaningTips community, a Redditor revealed how their usually durable Scrub Daddy sponges were shredding at an alarming rate, leading them to ask, "What's going on?" The post drew nearly 800 comments in two weeks.
"Bought new scrub daddies a couple months ago. This is what's left in the sink today after washing about 5 mugs," the original poster wrote, sharing an image of their sink filled with blue particles from their partially intact smiley face sponge.
"I can't believe how quickly this is disintegrating," they explained. "I'm having to pick pieces out of the sink every time I wash up. My old scrub daddy lasted literally years! Has anyone else noticed the new ones being significantly worse quality??"
One commenter confirmed they once had a Scrub Daddy that lasted years but suggested the newer ones they have purchased haven't been quite the same since household cleaning brand Cif (owned by Unilever) announced its partnership with Scrub Daddy in 2023. Another person agreed, saying, "It's so sad as they used to be my favorite sponges."
However, Scrub Daddy COO John O'Brien Jr. told The Cool Down that the problem this Redditor is describing is almost certainly because they accidentally bought an inferior knockoff.
"The product in question has nothing to do with any Unilever/Scrub Daddy collaboration," O'Brien said. "It is related specifically to counterfeit products being sold on Temu/Alibaba and, unfortunately, Amazon! We are conducting a full investigation but can confirm our manufacturing process, suppliers, recipe have not changed."
Why is this concerning?
The possibility that all customers lamenting the quality change on the post have been receiving counterfeit Scrub Daddies from Amazon and elsewhere may invalidate the concerns about a dip in durability and thus sustainability. While Amazon is generally considered to be a trusted major retailer, it does allow individual sellers on its platform who may ship a product direct to the consumer, and this opens up an opportunity for counterfeit products on the platform.
Scrub Daddy says on its website that the normal lifespan of its sponges is around two weeks. If they were to begin deteriorating sooner than that, the decrease in quality could lead consumers to shell out more money for replacements — which would in turn contribute to increased resource consumption.
O'Brien noted that Cif has not altered the composition of Scrub Daddy products. According to Design Life-Cycle, the original Scrub Daddies were made from a patented type of plastic derived from petroleum, a highly polluting dirty fuel, and are not particularly eco-friendly to begin with, as most Scrub Daddy customers choose the brand's sponges for their performance and smiley appearance rather than their sustainability.
As one Redditor put it: "Microplastics ... stop using plastic sponges folks."
Is Scrub Daddy doing anything to reduce waste?
The company explains in its product FAQs that tests are ongoing to determine whether its Scrub Daddies are biodegradable, but it notes they aren't recyclable.
The original Scrub Daddy blog states that the company is committed to sustainability, with the sponges non-toxic and produced with "eco-friendly manufacturing processes" — something Design Life-Cycle's finds call into question given the use of dirty fuels.
🗣️ When you're choosing health and beauty products, which of these factors is most important to you?
🔘 Cost 💰
🔘 Brand name 💅
🔘 Ingredients 🧪
🔘 Packaging 📦
🗳️ Click your choice to see results and speak your mind
Happily, the brand does encourage consumers to repurpose their old Scrub Daddies, giving them "a second life of cleaning" in the garage, backyard, or bathroom. The Cool Down has also previously covered and raised some concerns around what was likely a well-intentioned Scrub Daddy send-back program that involves having customers ship used sponges back to the company to be burned as fuel.
More encouraging is the brand now makes a dye-free version in reduced packaging as well as a more environmentally friendly product from coconut husks and recycled material, called the CocoMesh scrubber. While the recycled material still allows for more plastic waste than purely plastic-free sponges, it's certainly a step in the right direction.
What can be done to reduce household waste?
As one commenter highlighted, finding alternatives to plastic-based sponges is a savvy household move, eliminating the potential for toxic microplastic contamination.
Moreover, a two-pack of affordable zero-waste sponges could last as long as 20 disposable ones, particularly through the ability to microwave them to kill germs, which means you'll be spending less money on cleaning supplies.
"Bamboo scrubby brush," one commenter suggested.
Other durable, long-lasting plastic-free products include silicon Stasher bags and containers (in place of single-use sandwich bags). More broadly, there are also numerous money-saving, waste-reducing hacks to repurpose empty glass jars for food prep and storage.
Editor's note: After publish, a representative for Scrub Daddy asserted that the customer covered in this story must have purchased a counterfeit product. The article has been updated to include those comments and some additional context.
Join our free newsletter for good news and useful tips, and don't miss this cool list of easy ways to help yourself while helping the planet.
Cool Picks
